Hi everybody,
Sorry I’ve been away from this for awhile. I hope to never have that long of an absence again. Here is my latest post and thanks for reading and for your great comments.
So the federal government recently cracked down on “for profit” colleges – schools that issue degrees in technical fields supposedly in high demand and promise a high-paying career and a new lease on life. The reason for the crackdown? The schools are graduating students saddled with loan debt and no high-paying job prospects. So here’s my question:
Do film schools qualify for the crackdown?
When I heard this report on the radio, I thought about my years in Graduate School. Film schools aren’t much different than the culinary, beauty and “train to be a Medical Assistant” schools the government has determined need to be reined in. All these schools charge exorbitant tuition and make the same promise of wealth, a lasting career and a better existence. Upon further reflection, perhaps film schools are more egregious because they thrive on a formula of “dreams plus successful matriculation equals fame and fortune” with little-to-no mention of the astronomical odds of success.
This isn’t going to be an USC-bashing blog post. I bleed ‘Trojan blood” and my two years at USC were some of the best in my life; the culmination of a lifelong dream. In the 1970s, my cousin, Dr. Donald Reed, started the Academy of Science Fiction, Fantasy and Horror Films – a pioneering organization for genre films underrepresented in Hollywood at the time. His organization still exists and its “Saturn Award” remains a highly respected industry trophy. When I was a kid, my first exposure to film was through my cousin’s weekly film screenings at USC’s Norris Theater. I was fascinated by the University and made the vow that I was going to go to college there. My grades weren’t good enough for college, however, based on my burgeoning screenwriting talent, I was accepted into the prestigious, competitive School of Cinema-Television (now the School of Cinematic Arts) Graduate Screenwriting Program. I was one of only twenty-eight students accepted that year and the only African-American male.
My time at USC was glorious. Watching movies in same theater I sat in as a kid. Learning the history of film and the craft of writing from the best minds in the business. There was absolutely nothing better. The University even made it possible for me to see one of my ideas brought to life on the big screen – a short film about a drug-addled Jazz musician. So, I’m not discouraging film school at all. It’s a great place for gestating talent and cultivating relationships that will hopefully translate into future success. My issue with film schools can be summed up by the old saying, “It’s not about what’s said, it’s all about the unsaid”. Say nothing of the fact that two years of student loans equals twenty-four years of steady repayment (do your best to never take a deferment!), but in those two years, I can only remember one occasion when we were given an idea of how difficult it could be to achieve success in screenwriting.
On the last day of classes, the late John Furia, Jr., then Chair of the Writing Division, made a culminating speech. He emphasized the need for us all to make a five-year plan for success. At the end of five years, he suggested we evaluate our benchmarks of success and consider extending the five-year plan into a ten-year plan. Prior to his suggestion, I don’t remember anyone discussing in any great detail the perils of the journey we were undertaking. If they had, we probably would have listened with a jaundiced ear. The steady diet of positive re-enforcement we received over those two years made everyone believe to varying degrees that “failure is a possibility but success is imminent”. In hindsight, the reverse is true – success as a screenwriter is a possibility but the possibility of failure looms large.
There is a federal law called the TILA or “Truth In Lending Act” that exists to promote the informed use of consumer credit. Basically, a bank can’t give you a loan without telling you that you must pay the money back. In investing, there is an inherent understanding that most investments can and do result in you losing your money. I’m proposing the TIFS Act, the “Truth In Film School” Act. The requirement that a school inform students, as they matriculate, just how hard it will be attain the position they are training and paying for. Nestled among the beginning and intermediate screenwriting courses, there should be a course that invites alumni to come back and give talks about what they are currently doing in the entertainment business and what meandering path led them there. Believe me when I say, there would never be a shortage of speakers!
Of the twenty-eight students I graduated with over twelve years ago, one of is a full-time writer on a television series. Another is a screenwriter in film, two others work in television as producer/writers and one other makes independent films. The others work in other aspects of the business, have moved on from screenwriting ambitions, or still chase the elusive brass ring of their first script sale. Success is attainable in realms beyond screenwriting, but it’s based on redefining what success means to you (hence Mr. Furia’s advice).
Sometimes there is power in ignorance. After hearing Han Solo’s plan to evade TIE Fighters by flying the Millennium Falcon directly into an asteroid field, C-3P0 calculated the statistical probability of success and the survival of everyone on board. To which, Han Solo promptly countered:
“Never tell me the odds!”
Sure, Han was right in that case, but then, Han never tried to become a screenwriter. So a little pragmatism in pursuit of a dream can’t hurt. Even if the advice isn’t heeded at the time, at least no one can say they weren’t adequately warned. Do you hear me, film school department heads? Just offer one measly course on how the business REALLY is and how difficult it is to become a working writer. It won’t kill the dream, it will just educate the dreamers. Everyone’s experience is going to be a little different – some will struggle less, some will struggle more, others will have an uncle who’s a producer. That’s the way life works, but a little honesty could make a big difference. Until then, dear readers, this blog will just have to do.
