How to Use the ’36 Dramatic Situations’ as a Brainstorming Tool

By Jeff Kitchen · June 11, 2021

Everything in the room you’re in can be described from one point of view with the Periodic Table of Elements from chemistry.

The 118 elements that make up all matter that we know of. The chair you’re sitting on consists of hydrogen, oxygen, carbon, iron, and so on. You can describe that chair quite completely from one point of view.

Why are we talking about chemistry on a screenwriting blog? Because the concept is a lot like the The 36 Dramatic Situations, a tool for writers created in the late 1700s by Italian playwright Carlo Gozzi and then turned into a book in 1916 by Georges Polti.

It claims that all stories consist of 36 basic situations, like AmbitionMadnessRevoltDisasterPursuit, and more. Each has its own meaning and can conjure cascades of ideas in a writer who uses them to help create and develop a story. 

Let’s take a look at the 36 Dramatic Situations, break them down, and see if we can use them to build a story from scratch. Also, we’ll also go over a few fun writing and brainstorming exercises you can do to get your creative juices flowing.

The 36 Dramatic Situations

  1. Supplication—Asking or begging for help.
  2. Deliverance—Rescuing or being rescued.
  3. Crime Pursued by Vengeance—Seeking revenge for a crime.
  4. Vengeance Taken for Kin upon Kin—Revenge within a family or a tight-knit group.
  5. Pursuit—In pursuit of or being pursued by.
  6. Disaster—A disaster of any magnitude or context (even a bad hair day).
  7. Falling Prey to Cruelty or Misfortune—Bad things happening, either intentionally or not.
  8. Revolt—Rebelling against anything, in any context.
  9. Daring Enterprise—A bold adventure in any context, large or small.
  10. Abduction—A kidnapping of any kind, even if it’s capturing someone psychologically.
  11. The Enigma—A mystery; a riddle to be solved, of any magnitude.
  12. Obtaining—Trying to obtain something real or intangible.
  13. Enmity of Kin—Hatred between relatives or among a tight-knit group.
  14. Rivalry of Kin—Rivalry between kinsmen, in any kind of relationship.
  15. Murderous Adultery—Adultery, but with murder or murderous intent in any context.
  16. Madness—Insanity in any form, whether it’s a Jim Carrey comedy or Hannibal Lecter.
  17. Fatal Imprudence—Doing something unwise with fatal consequences (often metaphoric).
  18. Involuntary Crimes of Love—Similar to situation 26, but not intentional.
  19. Slaying of a Kinsman Unrecognized—Hurting someone you know without realizing who they are.
  20. Self-Sacrifice for an Ideal—Sacrificing oneself (often metaphorically) for what you believe in.
  21. Self-Sacrifice for Kindred—Giving of yourself, even your life, for love or duty.
  22. All Sacrificed for a Passion—Pouring everything you’ve got into what you believe in.
  23. Necessity of Sacrificing Loved Ones—Having to sacrifice someone you love.
  24. Rivalry of Superior and Inferior—Self-explanatory, but who really is the superior one? 
  25. Adultery—Literal adultery, or violating a trust of any kind.
  26. Crimes of Love—Often sexual, but can be any kind of violation in a close relationship.
  27. Discovering the Dishonor of a Loved One—Learning that someone you love is dishonorable.
  28. Obstacles to Love—Anything that blocks a love of any kind.
  29. An Enemy Loved—Falling in love with an enemy or respect for an enemy.
  30. Ambition—All types of ambition; even a total lack of ambition.
  31. Conflict with a God—Going up against any great power.
  32. Mistaken Jealousy—Being jealous, but for an incorrect reason.
  33. Erroneous Judgment—Making a bad choice, of any magnitude.
  34. Remorse—Feeling bad for something, or conversely, a total lack of remorse.
  35. Recovery of a Lost One—Getting back someone or something you’ve lost.
  36. Loss of Loved Ones—Losing someone or something you love.

Let’s Use Some of the 36 Situations to Build a Comedy

Say you’re writing a comedy about two idiot brothers who mistakenly win scholarships to Stanford and then accidentally invent anti-gravity when they blow up the physics lab. Some of the 36 situations would be inherent in this story idea before you even touch it. Obvious at first glance would be:

  • Disaster
  • Madness
  • Rivalry of Superior and Inferior
  • Erroneous Judgment
  • Ambition
  • Falling Prey to Cruelty or Misfortune
  • the Enigma
  • Daring Enterprise

All these elements already exist within this story idea before you even play with it. Disaster because you have these two idiots descending on this ivy league bastion of higher learning. Madness because they’re crazy, the situation is insane, the mess they create is lunacy, and they drive people nuts, etc.

Rivalry of Superior and Inferior is active because while these two are obviously inferior to others who are vastly superior, our idiots might have unexpected superior attributes that turn the tables, and the rivalry would be intense.

The story is rich with possibilities, which is what attracted you to it in the first place, but now that you can isolate and articulate more of the ways in which it’s rich, you can do even more with it. The main thing in working with the 36 is that you’re already building a story, inventing, creating, doing research, casting around for ideas, and brainstorming possibilities—and looking through the 36 Dramatic Situations as you create helps trigger even more ideas, some of which might never have occurred to you.

Playing “What If?”

Plus, you can play “What If?” with situations that aren’t in this comedy yet, but which might make it pop even more.

If they accidentally invented anti-gravity then there are world-changing fortunes to be made, and skullduggery would abound. With hundreds of trillions of dollars at stake, there would be betrayal, theft, lies, deception, loss, and maybe even murder.

So Conflict with a God and Crime Pursued by Vengeance would be central, as would All Sacrificed for a Passion, Discovery of the Dishonor of a Loved One, Loss of Loved OnesObtaining, and the Necessity of Sacrificing Loved Ones, to name a few. 

The Less Literally You Take the Situations, The More Use You Can Make of Them

Let’s play with Conflict with a God. That situation would have no religious connotation at all in this story—it’s just conflict with a great power. The trick with the 36 Dramatic Situations is to not take them literally. The more metaphorically or poetically you take them, the more ideas they can suggest. So in our comedy idea, great powers of every stripe would be rushing in to control an invention of this magnitude.

So, let’s brainstorm using Conflict with a God: What if the Chinese spies at Stanford find out about it just as the Russian spies do? What will the US military and the CIA do to contain and control this world-changing invention? What if their professor tries to take credit for the invention, and how far is he or she willing to go to get it? What if a Silicone Valley “god” swoops in and tries to sweet-talk/bully the brothers into a deal?

The Situations Can Work Both Ways

But what if the idiot brothers turn out to be geniuses in how they handle all these people trying to steal it and control it and muscle them out of the picture so that they’re the gods in the arena in a certain way? How does that play out?

How funny could it be if their innate wisdom about human nature helps them outfox all these sharks? How hard do the powers that be come down on them to tell how they invented anti-gravity? What if they blunder into a creative solution like Inspector Clouseau, who does everything wrong and still comes up smelling like roses? What if everyone thinks they really are geniuses and wants to harness their brilliance, but all they did was to set their pants on fire and blunder through an experiment in electromagnetism, then tried to put it out with liquid oxygen, creating a miniature supernova that lasted a microsecond and altered the fundamental properties of a piece of metal—and they couldn’t recreate it to save their lives?

The Situations Trigger Cascades of Ideas

By thinking about how Conflict with a God can suggest fresh ideas for the story, and then colliding it with An Enemy LovedMadnessDisasterthe EnigmaErroneous Judgment, and Daring Enterprise, you can be up to your eyeballs in cascading ideas that leap out at you faster than you can write them down.

Just Madness and Disaster combined suggest reams of hilarious possibilities, with the two brothers obviously embodying Madness and Disaster themselves. But by flipping it, you can see how the various predators embody Madness and Disaster in their own ways, and how these two elements could upend their plans for dominance. If each situation conjures ten ideas, then write them down because that’s their job. 

Suggesting Fresh Possibilities for Your Stories

The 36 Dramatic Situations is a nutrient-rich fertilizer for creating, developing, and constructing stories. Like a LEGO set, you can create literally any story of any genre with them.

  • They’re great at the beginning of the story-creation process because, like gasoline thrown on a fire, they help you explode with ideas.
  • You’ve already got ideas boiling out of you, and looking through the 36 can trigger dozens more ideas in every direction.
  • They’re great as you develop the story because they suggest fresh ideas to help break free of cliché and can help refine choices you’re making.
  • They’re great as you near completion of the story because now you’re facing a different array of things that need solutions and subtle refinements so that An Enemy Loved can shift a relationship in a complex but understated way. 

Breaking Out of Your Own Storytelling Habits

The 36 Dramatic Situations can also help you violate your own storytelling rut so that if you would normally finish a story one way, maybe contemplating Erroneous Judgment gets you thinking about an entirely different approach and you’ve suddenly got a fresh twist on your ending.

So it’s a simple enough tool, and its two main functions are to identify which elements are already built into your story before you touch it and to throw hand grenades into the idea to explode it into unexpected new dimensions.

And the fact that it covers one complete spectrum of ideas makes it a compact and efficient tool for catalyzing your creative thinking to new and different levels.